My Profile

Keep Up to Date:
Blog RSS
Blog
Forum RSS
Forum
Post New Topic Post Reply
Posted 4 Weeks ago
soul8o8
Expert Boarder
Posts: 97
graphgraph
User Offline
 
Possible spoilers if you haven't seen EpII... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Any theories as to the significance of Darth Tyrannus cutting off Anakin's hand in EpII? It's the right hand - the same hand that Vader cut off of Luke's in ESB and (I believe) of Vader's when Luke cut it off in ROTJ.

Forgive me if this has been discussed...I haven't seen anything on this yet.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 6 Days ago
Aneish
Expert Boarder
Posts: 117
graph
User Offline
 
Like father, like son.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 6 Days ago
soul8o8
Expert Boarder
Posts: 97
graphgraph
User Offline
 
Injury to the hand is a pretty common motif in heroic legends. One story where it's particularly important is the legend of Perceval and the Holy Grail. The Fisher King is one figure in the story and has a wound to the hand (and in some versions, the 'thigh' that won't heal. Perceval himself also burns his hand in some versions of the story. The Fisher King can only be healed by the Holy Grail, which is kept in the Grail Castle. Perceval has already encountered the castle once in his youth, where he gained admittance quite easily; when he has to deliberately return to it later, it's much more of an ordeal.

Anakin parallels both the Fisher King and Perceval (who at one point mistakes someone for an angel!), while Luke parallels Perceval. The Death Star, in its two incarnations, parallels the Grail Castle which Perceval visits twice.

Other characters you might know who get their hands or arms wounded include Johnny Tremain, Captain Hook, Thomas Covenant, the hero in 'Desperado', and Frodo Baggins. There are also a lot of stories where the hero or a figure important to the hero receives some other kind of wound (often a burn) or even just emotional harm that just won't heal. Anakin Skywalker eventually gets all three manifestations of this sort of harm: he loses his hand, he gets burned (or so we've heard), and he gets seduced by the Dark Side of the Force.

Some of these connections may sound like a bit of a stretch in the short descriptions I'm giving here. The more you learn about the patterns, though, the more apparent they are in different stories. There's a lot of psychological interpretation that begins with the idea that hands/arms are often phallic symbols. So a wound to the hand is symbollicaly an injury to a character's masculinity. Healing that injury is what drives a lot of heroic tales.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 6 Days ago
Alfgrs
Senior Boarder
Posts: 74
graphgraph
User Offline
 
That's only because they use their right hand to hold their Light Sabre, although in theory it's a two-handed weapon.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 6 Days ago
JohnCrown
Expert Boarder
Posts: 80
graphgraph
User Offline
 
it's the whacking-off hand...
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 6 Days ago
dabibibff
Expert Boarder
Posts: 104
graphgraph
User Offline
 
And Django!
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 5 Days ago
Brett-NZ
Expert Boarder
Posts: 80
graphgraph
User Offline
 
Lucas obviously likes british folklore. The story of...I think it's Parzival...kid who gets visited by Knights who find him to be 'special' and he eventually is given the choice to leave his mother and he does.

Come to think of it, this is the story where he mistakes the knights for angels, isn't it?

Very similar to Phantom Menace with the (Jedi) knights and mistaking Padme for an angel.

ON a simpler note, the loss of the arm is a symbol of Anakin losing his humanity (as a result of his choices). When Luke loses his hand and then cuts off Vader's, he realises that he is following in his father's
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 5 Days ago
pietersejl
Expert Boarder
Posts: 94
graphgraph
User Offline
 
There are lots of spellings for the character - Parsifal, Percival, Perceval, etc. - since there are numerous English, French, and German versions of the story. I'm glad you mentioned the mother in the story; that's an important parallel with Anakin.

Yep. I think it's particularly significant that Anakin mistakes a woman for an Angel rather than the Knights; it shows how he's following the wrong ideal from the start. Getting more complex, that ideal might not be entirely wrong. Luke is similarly motivated to start his adventures by the appearance of Leia, but this eventually leads him to a higher understanding of personal connnection than the old Jedi ever achieved.

True. That level of the symbolism is important, too.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 5 Days ago
masterpo
Senior Boarder
Posts: 66
graphgraph
User Offline
 
They're all right-handed.

It's funny. When Anakin got his arm trapped on the conveyor belt, I had a feeling he was going to lose it soon and he did.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 4 Days ago
Ricimer
Expert Boarder
Posts: 95
graphgraph
User Offline
 
I was lying dazed after being viciously attacked by a Wampa Ice Creature, when a ghostly image of Old Ben Kenobi appeared and said to me....

Actually Vader cuts off Luke's *left* hand. Maybe it means that Vader will become Plalp's **right-hand** man
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Posted 3 Weeks, 4 Days ago
johngnova
Expert Boarder
Posts: 91
graphgraph
User Offline
 
The main significance was what happened in ROTJ. Just as Luke was giving in and succumbing to the dark side, he takes Vader's hand. The moment he notices it is artificial, he looks to his own hand.

You can see the flash of insight as Luke realizes:

1) He's already started down the path Obi Wan warned him about. ('[Vader's] more machine now than man. Twisted and Evil.' 2) That Luke is also following the same path as his father did, giving in and using the dark side and that it came so easily.

The second significance is that this is the beginning of Anakin's path to his ultimate destiny. Becoming the entity Obi Wan was warning Luke against. He's lost a good portion of his arm only a few days after his first steps down the dark path. As the dark side overtakes him he'll lose the rest of his humanity until he becomes Vader.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
 
Copyright © 2006 - Oct 2008 Starwars Buddies