MY REVIEW

First off I will say overall I loved the movie. Ive seen three times already. Pros: I like all the action Ewan Magregor is great you can see evidence of the Older Obi Wans personality in his performance. Natailie Portman is beautiful, I loved all the dresses.

Cons: The dialog as written. Parts of it seemed stiff and too formal, not natural speach.

I still wonder if that's bad writting, or just the way he wanted the characters to come off. I mean Vader, other than when he was angry, didn't show much emotion, seemed like a machine, so the fact that Anakin comes off the same way, is it bad writing, or is that just how Anakin/Vader is?