anyone agree?

I personally think Lucas should have made sequals to episodes 4-6, this way he could use Mark Hamill, Carrie Fisher, and Harrison Ford. It would have been more interesting seeing the Solo children, especially little Anikan Solo, since he is so powerful and all in the books?! Also, I think what also made the pre-quals look bad, is the fact that Lucas used to much animation, he made everything look more advanced than in episodes 4-6... watch 1,2,4,5 and 6 all together and you will see what I mean!

Do you REALLY want to see the old, paunchy heroes going around being Jedi's and stuff again? That would be downright depressing.

I think that if Lucas is going to redo Episodes IV-VI he should redo them DRAMATICALLY. Ie, basically yank the actors out of the old prints and redo just about everything in CGI like he's done for Episode II. Not changing anything though.

That's IF. Personally, I would prefer he just left them as they originally were... no matter how scungy they look compared to the PT.

I don't think GL should yank out the actors, but I reckon CGI characters replacing aliens in Jabba's and Mos Eisley Cantina. That could be done.... New space battles, just tidied up. New computer terminal screens seen in the Falcon and Slave 1 etc